|“||It's just kind of hard finding your own kind. Your own people, you know?||„|
| — Caleb to Amenadiel|
in "Super Bad Boyfriend"
Caleb never felt he fit in with the YEA club, due to being black. He accidentally fell into a bad crowd when he felt more at ease with Tahir, who he didn't know was a drug dealer until it was too late.
After Ms Baez was murdered, Caleb tried to get a favor from Lucifer. He instead met Amenadiel, who offered to help him get out of the drug business. Leaving Amenadiel's necklace as collateral, Caleb was assured he could pay off the money Tahir expected from it. When done, they got ice cream; Amenadiel revealed he was expecting a son, so this experience helped him understand children better.
However, officers stopped them; a golf club in Caleb's locker was covered in the victim's blood. Despite obviously being stunned, Caleb was tackled to the ground. Amenadiel tried to diffuse the situation, but the officers grew aggressive until Dan arrived.
In holding, Caleb was visited by Amenadiel, who promised help as he knew he (Caleb) was innocent; however, Caleb pointed out he was a black kid who sold drugs, making him look guilty. However, Lexy was revealed to be the killer by her boyfriend and Caleb was released. Grateful, Caleb agreed to play some 1-on-1 with Amenadiel in the future.
However, no sooner was he free, Caleb was shot dead by Tahir. A furious Amenadiel later beat up Tahir to avenge Caleb.
Amenadiel later gave Caleb his necklace to honor him.
- Caleb was indirectly killed by Lexy.
- It is implied he went to Heaven, as Amenadiel looks up when visiting the morgue; Caleb had turned his life around and felt he had a second chance at life.